“Happiness doesn’t arrive with fanfare. It whispers in moments we almost miss whilst searching for something louder.”
Read on or listen here:
There’s a peculiar irony woven into modern life: we’ve created an entire industry dedicated to happiness – apps, courses, coaching, retreats – yet rates of depression and anxiety continue to climb. Self-help shelves groan under the weight of titles promising joy, yet we seem further from contentment than ever. What if the very pursuit of happiness is what’s keeping it at bay?
The Tyranny of Constant Joy
Walk through any bookshop and you’ll find entire sections devoted to happiness. Scroll through social media and encounter endless posts about “living your best life” and “choosing joy.” The message is relentless: if you’re not happy, you’re doing life wrong. Happiness has become both goal and obligation, aspiration and expectation.
But here’s what nobody mentions in those glossy Instagram posts: constant happiness isn’t just impossible, it’s undesirable. Happiness, like any emotional state, derives its power from contrast. When we pursue joy as a permanent condition rather than a fleeting visitor, we guarantee our own disappointment.
Psychologists call this the “hedonic treadmill” – the phenomenon where we rapidly adapt to positive circumstances, requiring ever-greater inputs to generate the same feeling. The promotion becomes your new normal within months. The relationship that once sparked joy settles into comfortable routine. The purchase that promised satisfaction becomes just another possession requiring maintenance.
We’re running faster and faster, chasing a happiness that recedes with each step forward.
What We Actually Want
During my year living wild in the Scottish Highlands, I experienced something unexpected: I wasn’t constantly happy. There were moments of profound joy – watching the sun rise over frost-covered hills, feeling my body grow stronger, sitting in perfect silence beside a burn. But there were also moments of discomfort, loneliness, physical pain, and genuine hardship.
Yet I felt something more valuable than happiness: I felt alive. Present. Connected. Content in a way that had nothing to do with pleasure and everything to do with meaning.
Here’s what I’ve come to understand through both lived experience and academic research: we don’t actually want constant happiness. What we want is a life that feels worth living – a life that contains beauty alongside difficulty, pleasure alongside challenge, joy alongside struggle.
Researcher Emily Esfahani Smith’s work demonstrates that people who pursue meaning rather than happiness report greater life satisfaction and resilience. Meaning encompasses purpose, belonging, storytelling, and transcendence – elements that often involve discomfort, sacrifice, and hardship.
The parents exhausted from caring for a newborn aren’t perpetually happy, yet they’re experiencing profound meaning. The artist struggling with a difficult project isn’t filled with constant joy, yet they’re engaged in work that matters. The activist confronting injustice isn’t cheerful, yet they’re living according to their deepest values.
Happiness is fleeting. Meaning endures.
The Neuroscience of Contrast
Our brains aren’t designed for constant positive emotion. Dopamine – the neurotransmitter associated with pleasure and reward – functions through anticipation and surprise, not sustained satisfaction. When we achieve a goal or receive a reward, dopamine spikes briefly, then returns to baseline. This is adaptive: if we felt perpetual euphoria after eating, we’d never be motivated to seek food again.
Research by neuroscientist Kent Berridge distinguishes between “wanting” and “liking” – the motivation to pursue rewards versus the pleasure of experiencing them. Our wanting systems are much more powerful than our liking systems. Evolution has made us excellent at desiring and pursuing, but deliberately bad at sustained satisfaction.
This isn’t a design flaw; it’s survival strategy. Our ancestors who felt contentment after finding food and never thought about the next meal didn’t leave descendants. We’re the children of restless strivers, and that restlessness served us well when resources were scarce and threats were real.
The problem? We’re applying ancient neurobiology to modern abundance. We’re using a scarcity-adapted brain in a world of plenty, and it’s making us miserable.
The Value of Scarcity
There’s a reason every spiritual tradition throughout history has incorporated periods of fasting, silence, solitude, or discomfort into their practices. They understood something we’ve forgotten: absence makes presence more powerful. Scarcity creates appreciation. Darkness makes light more brilliant.
When you’ve been genuinely cold, warmth becomes a gift rather than an expectation. When you’ve experienced real hunger, eating becomes a moment of profound gratitude rather than mindless consumption. When you’ve sat with loneliness, connection becomes precious rather than taken for granted.
I watch this transformation regularly in my work. Clients who’ve never experienced controlled discomfort often struggle with the smallest inconveniences – delayed trains, wrong coffee orders, slow WiFi. After learning to sit with genuine cold in wild water or navigate uncertainty during wild camping, those same triggers lose their power. They’ve recalibrated their nervous systems through contact with real challenge.
Research on “hedonic adaptation” shows that we rapidly adjust to positive circumstances, but we also adapt to challenges. This is why controlled exposure to manageable hardship builds resilience whilst constant comfort breeds fragility. We become robust through appropriate stress, weak through its absence.
The Science of Appropriate Discomfort
Here’s where the research becomes fascinating: our bodies and minds require some level of stress to function optimally. Complete absence of challenge doesn’t create wellbeing – it creates what researchers call “diseases of captivity.”
When zoo animals are kept in environments that eliminate all natural stressors, they develop stereotypic behaviours, metabolic disorders, immune dysfunction, and psychological problems. Remove physical challenges from daily life, maintain constant thermal comfort, provide unlimited food, and creatures that evolved for variable environments start breaking down.
Sound familiar?
Studies of hormesis – the biological phenomenon where low doses of stress strengthen systems – reveal that controlled exposure to cold, heat, hunger, and physical challenge all trigger beneficial adaptations. Your immune system strengthens. Your metabolism becomes more flexible. Your stress-response systems become more resilient. Your nervous system learns to shift between activation and recovery more effectively.
Dr. Rhonda Patrick’s research on cold exposure shows that regular immersion in cold water increases noradrenaline by up to 530%, improving focus, mood, and stress tolerance. Finnish sauna studies demonstrate that regular heat exposure reduces all-cause mortality by up to 40%. Intermittent fasting research reveals improvements in insulin sensitivity, cellular repair, and cognitive function.
The mechanism is consistent across all these practices: controlled stress triggers adaptation. Your body becomes stronger not despite challenge, but because of it.
Why We Need Hard Times
This isn’t about glorifying suffering or suggesting that genuine hardship is desirable. Chronic stress, trauma, and deprivation damage rather than strengthen. But there’s a critical difference between toxic stress and appropriate challenge, between being overwhelmed and being appropriately stretched.
Research distinguishes between distress (harmful stress) and eustress (beneficial stress). Eustress involves challenges that feel manageable with effort, that provide a sense of growth, that end with recovery. This is the stress of learning a new skill, having a difficult conversation, pushing physical limits within your capacity, or facing a fear in a controlled environment.
Hard times, when they’re time-limited and interspersed with recovery, teach us crucial lessons. They reveal capacities we didn’t know we possessed. They strip away the inessential and illuminate what truly matters. They forge genuine confidence – not the brittle, defensive kind built on avoiding difficulty, but the robust kind earned through proven capability.
My year in the wild was hard. Genuinely hard. There were nights of bone-deep cold, days of gnawing hunger, moments of fear and loneliness that no amount of positive thinking could eliminate. But those hardships didn’t diminish the experience – they defined it. They were the crucible in which a different version of myself was forged. And I’d do it again in a heartbeat, in fact, I am planning to, because despite all the hardship, it was the most profound experience of my life.
Practical Paths Forward
So how do we recalibrate in a world designed for comfort? How do we reintroduce appropriate challenge without manufacturing unnecessary suffering?
Start with voluntary discomfort. Choose manageable challenges that push your edges: a cold shower, a walk in poor weather, sitting with hunger before eating, a physical practice that requires effort, time in silence without digital distraction. These small doses of controlled stress rebuild your capacity for resilience.
Embrace the full emotional spectrum. Stop treating sadness, frustration, or discomfort as problems requiring immediate solutions. Sometimes difficult emotions contain important information. Sometimes sitting with discomfort teaches us more than fleeing towards pleasure.
Redefine success. If your metric for a good life is constant happiness, you’ve guaranteed disappointment. If your metric is growth, connection, meaning, and presence – with joy as a welcome visitor rather than permanent resident – you’ve created sustainable wellbeing.
Return to natural rhythms. Your body evolved expecting seasonal variation, periods of scarcity and abundance, cycles of activity and rest. Modern life flattens these rhythms into monotonous consistency. Deliberately reintroduce variation: feast and fast, intense effort and complete rest, social engagement and solitude.
Find your edges in nature. Whether it’s wild swimming, camping, foraging, or simply spending extended time outdoors in variable conditions, nature provides honest feedback about your capabilities. It’s neither punishing nor coddling – it simply is. Learning to meet it where it is, rather than expecting it to accommodate your preferences, builds genuine resilience.
The Quiet Contentment
Happiness, I’ve learned, doesn’t announce itself. It appears in unexpected moments – the warmth of morning light, the taste of simple food after genuine hunger, the silence after a storm, the easy laughter of old friends. These moments are precious precisely because they’re temporary, brilliant because they emerge from contrast.
Chasing happiness guarantees its escape. Creating conditions for meaning, growth, and presence allows happiness to find you – not as a permanent state, but as a fleeting grace that visits precisely when you stop demanding its appearance.
The silence of happiness is literal. It doesn’t broadcast itself, doesn’t require documentation, doesn’t need validation. It exists in the space between wanting and having, in the pause between breaths, in the moment before you label the experience.
Perhaps the question isn’t “How can I be happy?” but rather “How can I build a life worth living, regardless of my emotional state in any given moment?”
That question has better answers. And those answers don’t require constant joy – they require courage, presence, meaning, and the willingness to meet life as it actually is rather than how you wish it would be.
The wild places taught me this. They’re not designed for human happiness. They’re indifferent to our comfort, unimpressed by our preferences, unmoved by our complaints. Yet spending time in their honest company does something more valuable than making you happy: it makes you real.
And being real, even when it’s uncomfortable, beats chasing the illusion of constant happiness every single time.
To explore how controlled discomfort and nature immersion can build genuine resilience in your own life, get in touch, or follow along on social media for insights, practices, and upcoming wild experiences.
No responses yet